Dinner with a little attitude
Creamy three-cheese mac & cheese
Sharp cheddar, Gruyère, and pepper jack. Add buttery panko, try a spicy crunch, or keep it simply creamy.
- Prep time
- 15 min
- Cook time
- 35 min
- Total time
- 55 minutes
- Serves
- 6 servings
About 15 minutes prep, 35 minutes cooking, and 5 minutes resting. Pasta and sauce cooking overlap.

Your kitchen companion
Let’s make something good.
One original batch serves 6 as a main or 8 as a side. The selector uses main-dish servings. Use a baking dish that keeps the pasta at a similar depth when scaling; follow the original temperatures and doneness cues.
Make it yours. These are the ingredients and brands I like. Similar products are welcome. Open “What to buy & easy swaps” for help choosing.
Ready for the grocery aisle
Your shopping list
Tap each ingredient as you shop. Pantry staples count, too.
Your checks are saved on this device.
Mac and cheese
What to buy & easy swaps
Pasta aisle
Dry pasta in the shape named, or a similar-size shape. Buy by weight.
From my kitchen: Cavatappi is my favorite pick here. The spirals hold the sauce.
Make it yours: A similar short shape works. Check its package time and add liquid in small amounts if the pan dries before it is tender.
What to buy & easy swaps
Dairy case
Butter, salted or unsalted as written above. Use the tablespoon marks on the wrapper.
From my kitchen: I keep salted and unsalted Kerrygold.
Make it yours: Another butter brand works. With salted butter, taste before adding extra salt.
What to buy & easy swaps
Baking aisle
All-purpose flour, unless a different type is named.
Make it yours: A similar all-purpose flour works. Biscuit mix already has other ingredients and behaves differently.
What to buy & easy swaps
Dairy case
Whole or 2% dairy milk as written in the recipe.
From my kitchen: 2% grass-fed milk is what I keep in my fridge.
Make it yours: Regular milk of a similar fat level works. Whole milk is richer; 2% makes a lighter result.
What to buy & easy swaps
Dairy case
Heavy cream or heavy whipping cream.
Make it yours: A similar heavy cream works. Milk gives a lighter, thinner sauce and may need gentler heating.
What to buy & easy swaps
Cheese case
The cheese type listed above. Blocks usually melt smoothly when freshly grated.
Make it yours: Similar melting cheeses can be used by the same weight; the flavor and heat may change.
What to buy & easy swaps
Cheese case
The cheese type listed above. Blocks usually melt smoothly when freshly grated.
Make it yours: Similar melting cheeses can be used by the same weight; the flavor and heat may change.
What to buy & easy swaps
Cheese case
The cheese type listed above. Blocks usually melt smoothly when freshly grated.
Make it yours: Similar melting cheeses can be used by the same weight; the flavor and heat may change.
What to buy & easy swaps
Condiment aisle
Dijon mustard, or a similar mustard flavor you enjoy.
Make it yours: A similar mustard works; use a little less of a very strong one and taste.
What to buy & easy swaps
Spice aisle
The spice or blend listed above; read the salt and heat notes on the jar.
From my kitchen: Badia is my everyday spice pick; Spiceology is a flavor splurge.
Make it yours: A similar blend works. Start with less if it is salty or very hot, then taste.
What to buy & easy swaps
Spice aisle
The spice or blend listed above; read the salt and heat notes on the jar.
From my kitchen: Badia is my everyday spice pick; Spiceology is a flavor splurge.
Make it yours: A similar blend works. Start with less if it is salty or very hot, then taste.
What to buy & easy swaps
Spice aisle
Ground black pepper and the salt type listed above.
From my kitchen: Badia ground black pepper is my favorite; kosher salt is an everyday staple.
Make it yours: A similar ground pepper works. Salt grain sizes vary, so add a little and taste.
What to buy & easy swaps
Spice aisle
The salt type named above.
From my kitchen: Kosher salt is an everyday staple in my kitchen.
Make it yours: A similar salt works; crystal sizes differ, so season gradually.
What to buy & easy swaps
Dairy case
Whole or 2% dairy milk as written in the recipe.
From my kitchen: 2% grass-fed milk is what I keep in my fridge.
Make it yours: Regular milk of a similar fat level works. Whole milk is richer; 2% makes a lighter result.
Optional buttery panko topping
What to buy & easy swaps
Breadcrumb / cracker aisle
The breadcrumb or cracker type named above.
Make it yours: A similar topping works; salty, already-toasted crackers need a gentler finish.
What to buy & easy swaps
Dairy case
Butter, salted or unsalted as written above. Use the tablespoon marks on the wrapper.
From my kitchen: I keep salted and unsalted Kerrygold.
Make it yours: Another butter brand works. With salted butter, taste before adding extra salt.
What to buy & easy swaps
Cheese case
Parmesan from a block, or freshly grated Parmesan from the cheese counter.
Make it yours: A similar hard grating cheese works; add it off the heat and taste for salt.
One delicious step at a time
In the kitchen
A ship’s bell, with a nod to the Navy. Two strikes repeat every six seconds until you tap “Silence bell.” Keep this page open for sound; elapsed time is remembered when you return.
Prepare and grate
Heat the oven to 350°F. Butter a 9 x 13-inch baking dish. Buy 12 oz sharp cheddar, 8 oz Gruyère, and 4 oz pepper jack as blocks rather than pre-shredded cheese. Shred all three using the large holes of a box grater; freshly grated cheese melts more smoothly and makes a creamier sauce. Combine the shredded cheeses, then reserve 1 cup of the mixture for the top.
Cook the pasta
Bring a large pot of salted water to a boil. Cook 1 lb pasta 1-2 minutes less than the package directions for al dente. Drain without rinsing.
Build the sauce
Melt 6 tablespoons butter in a large saucepan over medium heat. Whisk in ⅓ cup flour and cook for 1 minute, stirring constantly. Slowly whisk in 3 cups milk and 1 cup cream until smooth. Bring to a gentle simmer and cook for 4-6 minutes, stirring often, until the sauce lightly coats a spoon. Stir in 2 teaspoons Dijon, ½ teaspoon garlic powder, ½ teaspoon smoked paprika, ½ teaspoon black pepper, and ¼ teaspoon salt.
Melt the cheese
Remove the saucepan from the heat and let it stand for 1 minute. Stir in all the cheese except the reserved 1 cup, a handful at a time, until smooth. Do not boil the cheese sauce. Taste and adjust the salt sparingly. If choosing the spicy cracker topping, remember that the crackers are salty.
Combine
Fold in the drained pasta. The mixture should be creamy and a little loose. If it seems stiff, stir in warm milk 1/4 cup at a time, up to about ½ cup. Transfer to the prepared dish and scatter the reserved 1 cup cheese over the top.
Prepare the optional buttery panko topping
Toss ¾ cup panko breadcrumbs with 2 tablespoons melted butter and ¼ cup grated Parmesan. Scatter over the reserved cheese.
Bake
Bake uncovered at 350°F for 20–25 minutes, until bubbling around the edges and lightly golden on top. Avoid baking until the whole pan bubbles vigorously, which can dry out the sauce. Rest for 5 minutes before serving.
Made to be shared
Look what you made.
Pull up a chair. You’ve earned this.
A few kitchen notes
Buy blocks of cheese and shred them using the large holes of a box grater. Pre-shredded cheese often contains anti-caking ingredients that can make the sauce less smooth. Freshly grated cheese gives a creamier result.
Keep the cheese sauce off the heat while adding the cheese, and avoid overbaking.
If Gruyere is unavailable, use an equal weight of additional sharp cheddar or pepper jack.
For stovetop mac and cheese, melt all the sharp cheddar, Gruyère, and pepper jack into the sauce, fold in the pasta, and serve immediately. Skip the baking steps. Add a topping to individual servings only if desired.
Reheat individual portions gently with a splash of milk, stirring as they warm.
A little help with dinner
Get my free guide: 5 Weeknight Dinners Dad Can Nail.
Good food. Less guesswork. Get five dinners for your weeknight rotation. See what’s inside →
While you’re here













