A family recipe, perfected over time
Homemade meatballs & sauce
Tender beef-and-pork meatballs simmered in silky garlic-confit tomato sauce, served with Frankies 457 cavatelli.
- Prep time
- 30 min
- Cook time
- 1 hr
- Total time
- About 1 hour 30 minutes
- Serves
- 8 servings
Times are guides. Start the garlic and tomato sauce while you prepare the meatballs. Cook the meatballs to 160°F in the center; their size and your pot affect the time.

Your kitchen companion
Let’s make something good.
The original batch uses 1 lb beef and 1 lb pork. Eight is the reference for scaling. Pasta is written for one 1 lb package; use the amount you want to serve.
Make it yours. These are the ingredients and brands I like. Similar products are welcome. Open “What to buy & easy swaps” for help choosing.
Ready for the grocery aisle
Your shopping list
Tap each ingredient as you shop. Pantry staples count, too.
Your checks are saved on this device.
Beef & pork meatballs
What to buy & easy swaps
Meat case
Ground meat, not stew cubes or a whole roast. Match the meat type and total weight.
Make it yours: A similar fat percentage works. If choosing ground poultry instead, cook it to 165°F rather than the beef/pork temperature.
What to buy & easy swaps
Meat case
Ground meat, not stew cubes or a whole roast. Match the meat type and total weight.
Make it yours: A similar fat percentage works. If choosing ground poultry instead, cook it to 165°F rather than the beef/pork temperature.
What to buy & easy swaps
Breadcrumb / cracker aisle
The breadcrumb or cracker type named above.
Make it yours: A similar topping works; salty, already-toasted crackers need a gentler finish.
What to buy & easy swaps
Dairy case
Whole or 2% dairy milk as written in the recipe.
From my kitchen: 2% grass-fed milk is what I keep in my fridge.
Make it yours: Regular milk of a similar fat level works. Whole milk is richer; 2% makes a lighter result.
What to buy & easy swaps
Egg case
Large eggs in a carton.
From my kitchen: Trader Joe’s heirloom eggs are a fridge favorite.
Make it yours: Any large eggs work in the stated amount.
What to buy & easy swaps
Bread aisle
Bread or buns sturdy enough for the filling.
Make it yours: A similar loaf or bun works. Thicker slices take longer to warm through.
What to buy & easy swaps
Bread aisle
Bread or buns sturdy enough for the filling.
Make it yours: A similar loaf or bun works. Thicker slices take longer to warm through.
What to buy & easy swaps
Spice aisle
The spice or blend listed above; read the salt and heat notes on the jar.
From my kitchen: Badia is my everyday spice pick; Spiceology is a flavor splurge.
Make it yours: A similar blend works. Start with less if it is salty or very hot, then taste.
What to buy & easy swaps
Spice aisle
The spice or blend listed above; read the salt and heat notes on the jar.
From my kitchen: Badia is my everyday spice pick; Spiceology is a flavor splurge.
Make it yours: A similar blend works. Start with less if it is salty or very hot, then taste.
What to buy & easy swaps
Cheese case
Parmesan from a block, or freshly grated Parmesan from the cheese counter.
Make it yours: A similar hard grating cheese works; add it off the heat and taste for salt.
What to buy & easy swaps
Spice aisle
The salt type named above.
From my kitchen: Kosher salt is an everyday staple in my kitchen.
Make it yours: A similar salt works; crystal sizes differ, so season gradually.
What to buy & easy swaps
Cooking oil aisle
The oil type written above. A neutral oil has little flavor.
From my kitchen: Grizzly olive oil is one of my cooking picks.
Make it yours: A similar cooking oil works. A strongly flavored oil will change the finished dish.
What to buy & easy swaps
Spice aisle
The spice or blend listed above; read the salt and heat notes on the jar.
From my kitchen: Badia is my everyday spice pick; Spiceology is a flavor splurge.
Make it yours: A similar blend works. Start with less if it is salty or very hot, then taste.
What to buy & easy swaps
Produce aisle
Fresh produce in the size or weight listed. Ready-chopped versions can save prep.
Make it yours: Similar vegetables can work, but cut them to the stated size and check tenderness; different vegetables cook at different speeds.
What to buy & easy swaps
From the tap
Use drinking water; measure the amount and temperature named above.
Make it yours: Use the cold or warm water called for in the step.
Garlic-confit San Marzano sauce
What to buy & easy swaps
Canned vegetables
Canned tomatoes in the form listed: crushed, whole, or stewed.
From my kitchen: Cento San Marzano tomatoes are a sauce favorite.
Make it yours: A similar tomato brand works. Whole tomatoes need breaking up; crushed tomatoes are already smoother.
What to buy & easy swaps
Canned vegetables
Canned tomatoes in the form listed: crushed, whole, or stewed.
From my kitchen: Cento San Marzano tomatoes are a sauce favorite.
Make it yours: A similar tomato brand works. Whole tomatoes need breaking up; crushed tomatoes are already smoother.
What to buy & easy swaps
From the tap
Use drinking water; measure the amount and temperature named above.
Make it yours: Use the cold or warm water called for in the step.
What to buy & easy swaps
Meat case
Raw Italian sausage, hot or mild as listed.
Make it yours: A similar Italian sausage works. Match links or loose meat to the recipe method.
What to buy & easy swaps
Produce aisle
Fresh produce in the size or weight listed. Ready-chopped versions can save prep.
Make it yours: Similar vegetables can work, but cut them to the stated size and check tenderness; different vegetables cook at different speeds.
What to buy & easy swaps
Cooking oil aisle
The oil type written above. A neutral oil has little flavor.
From my kitchen: Grizzly olive oil is one of my cooking picks.
Make it yours: A similar cooking oil works. A strongly flavored oil will change the finished dish.
What to buy & easy swaps
Dairy case
Butter, salted or unsalted as written above. Use the tablespoon marks on the wrapper.
From my kitchen: I keep salted and unsalted Kerrygold.
Make it yours: Another butter brand works. With salted butter, taste before adding extra salt.
What to buy & easy swaps
Soup / stock aisle
Boxed or canned broth in the flavor named above. Low-sodium gives you more control over salt.
Shopping guide: 1 × 32-fl-oz carton covers the measured amount. Other pack sizes work, too.
Make it yours: A similar broth works. Bouillon mixed with water according to its label is another option; taste before adding salt.
What to buy & easy swaps
Spice aisle
The salt type named above.
From my kitchen: Kosher salt is an everyday staple in my kitchen.
Make it yours: A similar salt works; crystal sizes differ, so season gradually.
What to buy & easy swaps
Spice aisle
Ground black pepper and the salt type listed above.
From my kitchen: Badia ground black pepper is my favorite; kosher salt is an everyday staple.
Make it yours: A similar ground pepper works. Salt grain sizes vary, so add a little and taste.
What to buy & easy swaps
Spice aisle
The spice or blend listed above; read the salt and heat notes on the jar.
From my kitchen: Badia is my everyday spice pick; Spiceology is a flavor splurge.
Make it yours: A similar blend works. Start with less if it is salty or very hot, then taste.
What to buy & easy swaps
Spice aisle
The spice or blend listed above; read the salt and heat notes on the jar.
From my kitchen: Badia is my everyday spice pick; Spiceology is a flavor splurge.
Make it yours: A similar blend works. Start with less if it is salty or very hot, then taste.
What to buy & easy swaps
Spice aisle
The spice or blend listed above; read the salt and heat notes on the jar.
From my kitchen: Badia is my everyday spice pick; Spiceology is a flavor splurge.
Make it yours: A similar blend works. Start with less if it is salty or very hot, then taste.
What to buy & easy swaps
Baking aisle
Granulated sugar, unless another type is named.
Make it yours: A similar granulated sugar works; add small amounts when balancing acidity.
What to buy & easy swaps
Canned tomatoes
Concentrated tomato paste in a can or tube.
Make it yours: A similar paste works. Tomato sauce is thinner and is not a spoon-for-spoon replacement.
Cavatelli & finishing
What to buy & easy swaps
Pasta aisle
Dry pasta in the shape named, or a similar-size shape. Buy by weight.
From my kitchen: Frankies 457 cavatelli is one of my pasta picks.
Make it yours: A similar short shape works. Check its package time and add liquid in small amounts if the pan dries before it is tender.
What to buy & easy swaps
Cheese case
Parmesan from a block, or freshly grated Parmesan from the cheese counter.
Make it yours: A similar hard grating cheese works; add it off the heat and taste for salt.
What to buy & easy swaps
Produce / fresh herb section
Fresh herbs when the ingredient says fresh; dried herbs are in the spice aisle.
Make it yours: Similar fresh herbs can change the flavor pleasantly. Dried herbs are stronger, so start with less.
What to buy & easy swaps
Spice aisle
The salt type named above.
From my kitchen: Kosher salt is an everyday staple in my kitchen.
Make it yours: A similar salt works; crystal sizes differ, so season gradually.
One delicious step at a time
In the kitchen
A ship’s bell, with a nod to the Navy. Two strikes repeat every six seconds until you tap “Silence bell.” Keep this page open for sound; elapsed time is remembered when you return.
Start the garlic confit
Put about 20 garlic cloves in a small saute pan and add enough olive oil to fully cover the cloves. The amount of oil depends on the size of your pan. Cook over low heat until the garlic is very soft and light golden. Lower the heat if it colors too quickly; keep the cooking gentle. Set it aside off the heat when ready.

What does confit mean?Confit (pronounced kon-FEE) is slow, gentle cooking in fat. Here, olive oil covers the garlic so it poaches over low heat until soft, mellow, and spreadable. Keep the heat low and avoid a vigorous sizzle. Get the tomatoes simmering
Add 2 28 oz cans Cento San Marzano tomatoes and all their juices to a large sauce pot. If using the optional stewed tomatoes, add 1 can with their juices now. Measure 1 full tomato can of water using one of the emptied San Marzano tomato cans. Swirl that measured water through the empty cans to rinse out every bit of tomato, then pour it all into the pot. Stir in ½ cup beef broth, kosher salt, Italian seasoning, dried oregano, and black pepper to taste. Add red pepper flakes if you want some heat. Cover and simmer gently for about 20 minutes while you prepare the meatballs.
Soften the breadcrumbs
Combine ½ cup Italian breadcrumbs with ¾ cup milk to start in a small bowl. Stir well, let stand about 5 minutes, then stir again.
Check the texture after resting: the mixture should be a soft, loose, oatmeal-like paste that mashes easily with a fork. If it has stiffened into a firm lump, stir in more milk a tablespoon at a time until it loosens. Break up any dry pockets before gently folding the soaked crumbs into the meat mixture. Use the texture as your guide; different breadcrumbs may need more milk.

Italian breadcrumbs and milkCheck the texture again after the five-minute soak. Add milk a tablespoon at a time as needed for a soft, loose paste that stirs and mashes easily before folding it into the meat mixture. Puree the onion
Blend ½ white onion with about ¼ cup water, adding only as much water as needed to make a puree. A good guide is just enough water to cover roughly half the chopped onion in the blender or food processor.
Gently bring the mixture together
In a large bowl, combine 1 lb ground chuck and 1 lb ground pork. Add the soaked breadcrumbs, 1 large egg, 1 bunch minced parsley, 1 bunch minced basil, ½ head minced garlic (preferably roasted, or 1 tbsp garlic powder), 1 tsp oregano, 1 cup freshly grated Parmesan, kosher salt, 2 tbsp olive oil, the onion puree, and optional pepper flakes or cayenne.
Fold gently until evenly combined. The mixture is meant to feel very soft and sloppy; avoid packing or overworking it.

Grate from a blockUse a box grater to freshly grate Parmesan from a block for the meatball mixture and for serving. Cook a tester and adjust
Pan-fry a small piece of the mixture until its center reaches 160°F. Taste the cooked tester, then adjust the salt or other seasonings in the remaining mixture if needed.
Roll the meatballs
Roll into meatballs about 2–2½ inches across, handling the soft mixture gently. Keep the sizes even so they cook at a similar rate.
Blend the sauce until silky
Lift the soft, golden confit garlic out of its oil and add the cloves to the simmering tomato sauce. Reserve the flavored oil separately. Blend the sauce in the pot with an immersion blender, keeping the blade submerged to avoid splashing.
Stir in 3 tbsp grass-fed butter. Taste and adjust the salt, black pepper, Italian seasoning, and oregano. Add red pepper flakes if you want more heat. If the sauce tastes too acidic, add sugar 1 teaspoon at a time, tasting after each addition.

Ready for the sauceLook for very soft cloves with a light golden color. Lift them out of the oil and add them to the tomatoes, reserving the garlic-infused oil separately. Cook the meatballs right in the sauce
Carefully lower the raw meatballs into the gently simmering sauce. If using the optional 5 hot Italian sausage links, add them whole to the sauce now. Use a wide enough pot for the batch and keep the heat gentle so the tender meatballs hold their shape. Avoid vigorous stirring while they set.
Cook until the centers of the meatballs and any sausage links reach 160°F on a food thermometer. Start checking around 25–30 minutes; larger meatballs, sausage links, or a crowded pot may take longer. The timer is a reminder to check, not proof that they are done.
If the sauce is too thin at the end, gently stir in tomato paste a little at a time. Keep it at a gentle simmer until it reaches the thickness you like, then taste and adjust the seasonings before serving.

At the start of the simmerThe meatballs are just starting to cook here. Keep the sauce at a gentle simmer and check the centers with a food thermometer for 160°F. Cook your cavatelli
Near the end of the meatball simmer, bring a pot of water to a boil and salt it. Cook 1 lb Frankies 457 cavatelli until al dente, following the timing on your package. Drain.
Spoon, grate, and serve
Serve the cavatelli with the meatballs and a generous spoonful of sauce. Serve any sausage links whole or sliced alongside. Finish with freshly grated Parmesan and chopped fresh Italian parsley. Use the pasta amount that suits your table.

Ready for the tableFinish with freshly grated Parmesan and fresh Italian parsley, then serve with the cavatelli and plenty of sauce.
Made to be shared
Look what you made.
Pull up a chair. You’ve earned this.
A few kitchen notes
Cento San Marzano tomatoes and Frankies 457 cavatelli are my personal favorites. The original recipe specifies two large tomato cans; this page uses two 28 oz cans.
Keep the garlic for the meat mixture separate from the confit garlic for the sauce. Keep the meatball olive oil separate from the confit oil, which is reserved after the cloves are lifted out.
For garlic confit, use enough olive oil to cover the cloves rather than relying on a fixed cup measure. A snug pan uses less oil. Lift the cooked garlic into the sauce and reserve the flavored oil separately.
Herb bunches vary. Use the fresh parsley and basil you normally use for this recipe, and rely on the fully cooked tester to dial in the seasoning.
Breadcrumb texture: Start with ¾ cup milk for ½ cup Italian breadcrumbs, then adjust after the five-minute soak. Add more milk a tablespoon at a time if the mixture becomes firm; it should be soft, loose, and easy to mash. If a firm breadcrumb clump is already in the mixing bowl, break it into small pieces and gently work in a little more milk as you fold everything together.
Save the garlic oil: The olive oil left from the confit is full of garlic flavor. Cool it promptly in a clean, heatproof container, then transfer it to a clean bottle or jar with a lid. Refrigerate promptly at 40°F or below, label with the date, and use within 4 days of cooking, or freeze in small portions for longer storage. Use it to brush onto bread, toss with pasta, or drizzle over vegetables.
Make the sauce your own. Use Italian seasoning, oregano, and black pepper to taste, with red pepper flakes for as much heat as you like. Taste as you go. If the finished sauce is too thin, add tomato paste a little at a time and simmer gently until it reaches the consistency you want.
Stewed tomatoes are optional, but I usually add a can to the original batch, juices and all. Add them with the San Marzano tomatoes before simmering and blending the sauce.
Hot Italian sausage is optional. Add 5 hot Italian sausage links to the sauce alongside the meatballs for a little extra heat and richness. The finished dish pictured includes sausage.
A little help with dinner
Get my free guide: 5 Weeknight Dinners Dad Can Nail.
Good food. Less guesswork. Get five dinners for your weeknight rotation. See what’s inside →
While you’re here













