← All recipes

Make the most of leftover sauce

Spicy vodka sauce

Turn leftover San Marzano tomato sauce into a rich, creamy vodka sauce with freshly grated Parmesan and as much heat as you like.

Prep time
5 min
Cook time
20 min
Total time
About 25 minutes
Serves
6 servings

Allow about 25 minutes for the sauce using plain vodka and red pepper flakes. The overnight infusion is an optional way to add heat.

Orecchiette and meatballs coated in creamy spicy vodka sauce, finished with freshly grated Parmesan and fresh Italian parsley in a white bowl
Spicy vodka sauce with orecchiette, meatballs, freshly grated Parmesan, and fresh Italian parsley.

Your kitchen companion

Let’s make something good.

2–8 people

Start with 4 ladles of homemade tomato sauce for a generous batch, with extra to save for another day. The 4–6 servings are a guide; ladle size and pasta portions vary. Adjust the servings below to scale the ingredients. Calories are a reference estimate for the sauce only.

Make it yours. These are the ingredients and brands I like. Similar products are welcome. Open “What to buy & easy swaps” for help choosing.

Ready for the grocery aisle

Your shopping list

Tap each ingredient as you shop. Pantry staples count, too.

Your checks are saved on this device.

0 ingredients checked

For the sauce

  • What to buy & easy swaps

    Produce aisle

    Fresh produce in the size or weight listed. Ready-chopped versions can save prep.

    Make it yours: Similar vegetables can work, but cut them to the stated size and check tenderness; different vegetables cook at different speeds.

  • What to buy & easy swaps

    Dairy case

    Butter, salted or unsalted as written above. Use the tablespoon marks on the wrapper.

    From my kitchen: I keep salted and unsalted Kerrygold.

    Make it yours: Another butter brand works. With salted butter, taste before adding extra salt.

  • What to buy & easy swaps

    Pasta sauce aisle

    A jarred tomato sauce you enjoy; arrabbiata is the spicy kind.

    Make it yours: A similar jar works. Taste before adding more salt or chili.

  • What to buy & easy swaps

    Spirits section

    Plain, unflavored vodka for the sauce.

    Make it yours: A similar plain vodka works; flavored versions change the sauce.

  • What to buy & easy swaps

    Spirits section

    Plain, unflavored vodka for the sauce.

    Make it yours: A similar plain vodka works; flavored versions change the sauce.

  • What to buy & easy swaps

    Cheese case

    Parmesan from a block, or freshly grated Parmesan from the cheese counter.

    Make it yours: A similar hard grating cheese works; add it off the heat and taste for salt.

  • What to buy & easy swaps

    Dairy case

    Heavy cream or heavy whipping cream.

    Make it yours: A similar heavy cream works. Milk gives a lighter, thinner sauce and may need gentler heating.

  • What to buy & easy swaps

    Spice aisle

    Ground black pepper and the salt type listed above.

    From my kitchen: Badia ground black pepper is my favorite; kosher salt is an everyday staple.

    Make it yours: A similar ground pepper works. Salt grain sizes vary, so add a little and taste.

Everything in the bag?

One delicious step at a time

In the kitchen

0 of 6 steps complete

A ship’s bell, with a nod to the Navy. Two strikes repeat every six seconds until you tap “Silence bell.” Keep this page open for sound; elapsed time is remembered when you return.

  1. Soften the shallot

    Melt a little butter or warm a drizzle of olive oil in a wide saucepan over medium-low heat. Add 1 large shallot, finely chopped, and cook until softened, stirring often.

    Chopped shallot softening in a wide saucepan
    Start with the shallotSoften the chopped shallot before adding the vodka.
  2. Add the vodka

    Measure ½–1 cup vodka, starting with the smaller amount. Take the pan off the heat and slowly pour in the vodka while stirring so it does not splash. Return to medium-low heat and let it simmer and reduce slightly. Add red pepper flakes to taste. If you have prepared the optional overnight infusion in the notes below, use it to replace some or all of the plain vodka.

  3. Add the tomato sauce

    Add 4 ladles leftover homemade San Marzano tomato sauce, removing any meatballs first. Stir it into the shallot and vodka.

    Simmer gently for about 10–15 minutes, stirring occasionally. Some alcohol remains after cooking.

  4. Stir in the cream

    Reduce the heat to low. Stir in ½–1 cup heavy cream, starting with the smaller amount, until the sauce is pink and creamy. Warm gently for a few minutes, keeping it below a boil.

  5. Finish with Parmesan

    Over very low heat or off the heat, gradually stir in ½–1 cup freshly grated Parmesan until smooth. Start with the smaller amount and add more to taste. Taste for salt and black pepper once the cheese has melted.

    Freshly grated Parmesan on a wooden board beside a pan of pink vodka sauce
    Grate it freshGrate Parmesan from a block, then stir it into the sauce over very low heat or off the heat.
  6. Toss with pasta and serve

    Toss cooked orecchiette, cavatelli, or your favorite pasta with as much warm sauce as you need. Add meatballs if you like, and finish with more freshly grated Parmesan and fresh Italian parsley. Save the remaining sauce for another day.

A few kitchen notes

I used four ladles of homemade tomato sauce. The finished vodka sauce made a generous batch, with plenty left for another day. Ladle sizes vary, so use the sauce's consistency as your guide.

Start with the smaller amounts of vodka, cream, and Parmesan. Taste as you go, adding a little more cream and cheese for a richer sauce.

Optional overnight infusion: Combine 1 cup vodka and about 2 tbsp red pepper flakes in a glass. Cover and let the flakes soak in the vodka overnight, then blend at room temperature in a Vitamix. Use it to replace some or all of the plain vodka, adding it gradually to control the heat.

Serve with orecchiette, cavatelli, or your favorite pasta, cooked according to the package directions. Orecchiette with meatballs, freshly grated Parmesan, and fresh Italian parsley is pictured; the meatballs and parsley are optional.

While you’re here

Something else for the table.

Cook Mode

Spicy vodka sauce

Step 1 of 66 servings